Valedictory Ceremony for Her Honour, Mrs Kirsty-Ann Gunn, Magistrate of the Summary Court


Reflections on her twenty years of service since arriving in the Cayman Islands as Crown Counsel were shared by the Chief Justice and senior members of the legal fraternity at the Valedictory Ceremony held in her honour on Friday, 16 January 2026.

As the Chief Justice delivered the first of the tributes from the three speakers that Friday afternoon, the guest of honour was at times visibly emotional, listening attentively to remarks that reflected both professional respect and the significance of the occasion.

What follows are the remarks delivered by the Chief Justice at the ceremony:

“This valedictory marks both an ending and a new beginning for Her Honour Mrs Kirsty Ann Gunn, Magistrate of the Summary Court. I am pleased to offer some remarks on behalf of the Judiciary, her colleagues in the Magistracy and all Court staff as we gather to say farewell to Her Honour Mrs Gunn who sits in these Courts for the last time.

I have known Mrs Gunn for almost twenty years since she first appeared in front of me in 2006 as newly appointed Crown Counsel. Even then, she stood out. She was always well prepared, measured in her submissions, and possessed of a calm authority that is not easily acquired so early in one’s career. She understood not only the law, but the responsibilities that accompany its exercise as a member of the Public Bar and ‘minister of justice’.

Her career thereafter took her to Bermuda, where she broadened her experience and perspective. In 2011, she responded to an advertisement for a Magistrate. She approached me for a reference, and it was not difficult to respond positively to the request. By that stage, she had already demonstrated the qualities essential to judicial office: intellectual rigour, integrity, independence, and an instinctive sense of fairness.

Since her appointment, Mrs Gunn has served this court with distinction, approaching her judicial role with seriousness of purpose and consistency of principle. Her decisions have been careful, well-reasoned, and grounded in the law. She has never treated the work of this court as routine, nor the individuals who come before it as anonymous. She has understood that for many litigants, the Summary Court represents their sole encounter with the justice system, and she has acted accordingly.

What has particularly characterised her service is balance. She has combined firmness with courtesy, efficiency with patience, intellectual rigour with humanity, particularly in the conduct of matters in our Treatment or Diversion Courts.

These are the hallmarks of a good judge, qualities that were recognised by the JLSC who recommended her appointment as an Acting Judge of the Grand Court to the Governor in 2017. She has acted on several occasions, most recently in a jury trial in summer of last year.

She has also been a valued colleague. She has contributed thoughtfully to discussion, supported newer members of the bench, and earned the respect of counsel and court staff alike. This is reflected in remarks her marshal, Jordan Thompson, asked me to convey, in which he thanks her particularly for the time she took to answer his questions and to help him develop a clear understanding of the work we do.”

Turning to her new appointment overseas, the Chief Justice stated that Mrs Gunn’s appointment as a Circuit Judge was both richly deserved and entirely unsurprising. She noted that it represented recognition of Mrs Gunn’s ability, judgement, and commitment to public service, adding that while her departure from the Summary Court was regretted, there was pride in seeing her progress to the next level of judicial responsibility.

The Chief Justice concluded by thanking Mrs Gunn for her years of dedicated service as a Magistrate and wishing her every success in her new role as a Circuit Judge.

The Chief Justice’s comments were echoed by speakers at the ceremony.

The Solicitor General, Ms. Reshma Sharma KC stated,

“I wish to extend our sincere gratitude to Her Honour for her stellar judicial service, for exemplifying fearlessness, patience, integrity, equanimity and firm fairness in her dealings with litigants and counsel alike, and her unwavering commitment to the rule of law. To paraphrase Socrates, for hearing courteously; answering wisely; considering soberly and deciding impartially. Those appearing before Her Honour in important, highly emotional and often difficult matters under the Children Act have unhesitatingly described her as a great asset to the jurisdiction in relation to the safeguarding of children. Her absence will be profoundly felt in this area.“

Chairman of the Criminal Defence Bar Subcommittee of the Cayman Islands Legal Practitioners Association (CILPA), Ms Prathna Bodden, said,

“Magistrate Gunn showed dedication, patience, kindness and impartiality daily whilst managing busy court lists with vulnerable defendants, emotional witnesses and all those who were involved in the Criminal Justice system. From her time at the DPP’s office, she was a mentor and inspiration, the first Crown Counsel to be appointed as a specialist in Financial Crime, she went on to provide support and guidance to her Marshall’s in Court, the lawyers practicing around, the working mothers and fellow Judges. She has a wealth of knowledge and experience, has assisted in developing the Jurisprudence of these islands. She leaves a legacy of excellent, reasoned, and thoughtful judgements which are used daily by practitioners. We have no doubt she will be a huge success as a Circuit Judge, and we hope she will return to these islands one day, a place which will always be her home.“

The Director of Public Prosecutions, Mr Simon Davis, speaking on behalf of the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, conveyed the high regard in which Magistrate Gunn was held for the balance and impartiality she consistently demonstrated from the Bench. He noted that her approach set exacting standards and required all appearing before her to discharge their duties to the Court and to their clients with the utmost professionalism.

Former Chief Magistrate Mr Valdis Foldats made an unexpected appearance at the ceremony and, at the invitation of the Chief Justice, also addressed the gathering. He spoke warmly of the collegial relationship he shared with Magistrate Gunn during his tenure as Chief Magistrate, sharing particular examples of her love for the law and how the Magistrate never shied away from tasks, no matter how difficult.

Following the conclusion of the ceremony, attendees gathered in the foyer of the Law Courts, where light refreshments were served and colleagues had the opportunity to extend their farewells.

The Chief Justice presents Magistrate Gunn, (left), with a Plaque of Honour, which was inscribed with the following words: “In recognition of your 13 years of service to the Judiciary and to the people of the Cayman Islands.”
Chief Magistrate, Her Honour Ms Angelyn Hernandez, (left) presents Magistrate Gunn with a gift from the judiciary.
L-R Simon Gunn, husband of HH Mrs Gunn, Former Chief Magistrate Foldats (standing) and Dr Jevon Alcock of the OAG.

Stay Updated!

Subscribe to get our latest news and events right to your inbox.